Everyone's Arguing About the Door: A Tutor's Take on Social Media Bans

September - October, 2021. Frances Haugen steps forward to expose, among many other issues, how Meta's own internal research recognized its contribution to body image issues, anxiety, depression, and addiction, particularly among teenage girls.1
March 26, 2024. Jonathan Haidt publishes The Anxious Generation and kicks off a movement for youth social media, and even smartphone, bans.2
December 10, 2025. Australia's world-first nationwide social media ban for "under-16s" takes effect.3
June 10, 2026. Canada follows suit, introducing Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act, which, among other safety measures, places age restrictions on mainstream social media apps.4
June 15, 2026. UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer announces a plan to ban children under 16 from mainstream social media apps like YouTube, Snapchat, TikTok, and Instagram.5
Every one of these responses has something in common. A whistleblower's testimony, a bestselling book, and three governments, all aimed at the door. Legislation can restrict who walks in, but it has no mechanism for what happens to a kid once they're already inside the room. And we've got a whole generation or two already inside the room.
Of course, not everyone agrees the door should be closed. Dr. Candice Odgers, one of Haidt's most prominent critics, argues that social media is far from the most decisive factor in youth mental health.6 The American Psychological Association (APA) has warned that age limits alone won't protect kids,7 urging instead that we scaffold access the same way we'd teach a teenager to drive, as Dr. Mary Alvord puts it.8 Keep a kid away from the wheel, and they grow up with no practice reading the road. Let them in unsupervised, and they crash before they've learned to see the risk. The problem is that both sides are still negotiating the door. Nobody is asking what happens to the kid once they're already in the car.
What About the Tutor?
And this is all fascinating for the parent, the politician, and the policy-maker. But what about tutors like me? I have no say how much or how little my students interact with social media. I figure that gives me two options:
The easy option would be to cop out and say it's not my problem. All I have to do is help with homework, provide support for new and familiar concepts, and make sure they're keeping up with the curriculum.
But as a tutor, a coach, and even as a student of literature, I know I have the same duty to my students that teachers and even parents do. It's vital that a young adult learns how to analyze sources of information and truth. The digital age has stretched our understanding of literacy beyond reading and writing, and the core skill shared across digital and media literacy is source assessment and critical thinking.
So what should I do?
One of the hallmarks of refined critical thinking is being able to identify cognitive dissonance. It takes self-awareness, intellectual humility, and, perhaps most importantly, comfort with ambiguity. Unsurprisingly, I see this skill developed most in my executive function coaching. Meeting with a student every week and having them notice how their habits, conscious or not, show up in their results is indeed a practice of both metacognition and reckoning with cognitive dissonance. Tutoring offers the same opportunity. A student's quick, instinctual answer with no clear reasoning behind it is a chance to practice those same skills. In coaching and tutoring alike, the way in is the same: those moments of silence.
Sitting in the Silence
Creating those moments means letting students sit with questions uncomfortably long. For instance, my Grade 12 English student "P" and I were discussing, for the first time, where meaning comes from in a literary text. Is it the author? The text? The reader? Here's a paraphrased version of our conversation:
P: Well of course, the meaning comes from the text itself.
Me: Oh interesting, why do you say that?
P: Well that's what we've always been taught in school. The source of meaning is from the text because that way it's untouched by the author and the reader. The latter two are too difficult to nail proper interpretations from.
Me: So because it's difficult, the reader and the author can't have interpretations.
P: Well yeah, wait no that doesn't make sense…
Me: Alright, give it a think if you're not sure.
P talks himself through it out loud for a few minutes, none of it landing.
P: Okay, I don't really know what I'm talking about. Can you help?
Me: Walk me through it again. Where do you feel like you got lost?
He does, and somewhere in the retelling I ask him what he's left out. Not a new question, just his own first sentence, the one about school, sitting untouched since he said it. He hadn't lost the thought. He'd just stopped trusting it once the theory got hard. From there we talk about pedagogy taking precedence over literary theory, and why a school might teach one answer when the honest answer is that no one's settled it. I tell him I don't know the right answer either. That I'm not even sure there is one.
The riveting part of that conversation, to me, isn't the theory. It's that P already had what he needed in his first sentence. He just needed to sit long enough in not knowing to remember he'd said it.
It's not just the one student either. I've seen this work especially well with the textbook athlete, the student who does all their homework out of muscle memory, and the BSer, the student who gives a lightning-quick answer with no explanation of how they got there. P's problem was never about being wrong. It was about having a conclusion and forgetting the reasoning. Given the opportunity and the right scaffolding, students are very capable reasoners.
So the problem isn't ability. It's sourcing. School is hardly the only place a kid gets handed the answer first, and these days it's more likely to come from a screen.
A Sourcing Problem
Our new funnel for information is now digital. TikTok, YouTube, Instagram. Clickbait content and 60-second videos on concepts and practices turned into hacks or arbitrarily graded S-tier or D-tier have replaced long-form content and articles. It's not just the length that's changed. It's that these formats present information as some final ruling.
"This is S-tier!" "This exercise is a scam." "Here's ONE hack that instantly fixes your sleep."
Whatever reasoning the content creator used to arrive at these conclusions always comes after, if at all. The hook is the conclusion itself. Kids, and adults too, scroll through hundreds of reels and shorts in an evening. They aren't being lied to so much as they are being handed finished conclusions. By the time a student can vote, argue, or just hold an opinion at the dinner table, they've already had thousands of reps at receiving conclusions and almost none at arriving at them through reasoning.
That's the tragedy for me. All through school, students read the same instructions on their homework: "Explain your reasoning." "Justify your answer." "Show your work." But those reps are a drop in the bucket next to the hours they spend online. To call this a media literacy problem would sell it short. Media literacy is a bonus that comes with being a strong critical and metacognitive thinker. What I want to build in my students is the reflex to ask "why do I think this?" before saying an answer out loud.
I'm aware how backwards this might sound, but when we're young, the highest stakes are social. One of my most painful habits as a young learner was being afraid of what people would think of me if I said the wrong thing. Don't ask questions because they might be stupid questions. Don't answer unless I'm 100% sure I'm right, or that I'm saying something insightful. Don't post in the group chat if it might out me as uninformed. The work I'm describing is necessarily awkward, so it has to happen somewhere private and low-stakes.
For me, that place is the novel study. When P and I sit down with a book, we share a language: literary/poetic devices, grammar, sentence structure, diction, etc. And we have questions that don't need to be settled to be worth asking. No one else is watching. If his first answer falls apart, it falls apart in front of me and nobody else. That's exactly what makes it the right place to practice a skill he'll need far more on his feed than on any English exam. At the end of the day, what I can do as a tutor is use our time to sit with a student in the gap between "I have an answer" and "I know where it came from."
So, to ban or not to ban?
I still don't get a vote. I don't control anyone's parental settings. That power is far from mine. My problem with the ban question is the one I started with: it treats the feed as the whole battlefield, as if the only choices are letting kids in or keeping them out.
What I do have is sixty minutes with a student. No algorithm or summarized content to steer our thinking. Using that hour well has nothing to do with winning the ban argument. It's about making sure my student understands that their reasoning matters, and not just as a skill for school. I don't get to cop out and say all I can focus on is the curriculum. It's my job to use the curriculum to build the muscle that's missing.
Maybe policy-makers and parents will fix the landscape eventually. Maybe they won't. Either way, P and the rest of my students don't have time for me to wait and see. A finished essay was never the point of tutoring. The point is to have someone ask you to look at your own thinking and decide whether it holds up.
P didn't need his feed banned to find where his answer came from. He just needed someone to ask him to go back and look.
Notes
- Shannon Bond, "Whistleblower tells Congress that Facebook products harm kids and democracy," NPR, October 5, 2021. npr.org ↩
- Jonathan Haidt, The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness (Penguin Press, 2024). penguinrandomhouse.com ↩
- eSafety Commissioner, "Social media age restrictions hub." esafety.gov.au ↩
- Government of Canada, "Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act." canada.ca ↩
- "PM Announces Under-16 Social Media Ban In 'Big Moment For Our Country'," PoliticsHome, June 15, 2026. politicshome.com ↩
- Candice L. Odgers, "The great rewiring: is social media really behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?" Nature 628 (2024): 29–30. nature.com ↩
- American Psychological Association, "APA report calls on social media companies to take responsibility to protect youth," April 16, 2024. apa.org ↩
- Kirsten Weir, "Social media brings benefits and risks to teens. Psychology can help identify a path forward," Monitor on Psychology 54, no. 6 (September 2023). apa.org ↩
This essay was originally published on my Substack here.

Nicholas Kwong
Nicholas Kwong is the co-founder of TutorShark and an executive functioning skills coach with a background in English and Mathematics from Queen's University. He specializes in one-on-one education with a focus on building the soft skills and cognitive habits that drive long-term student success.


